Barça’s Unethical Signing of Arda Turan.

Arda Turan’s signing by Barça is yet another unprofessional and unethical move by Bartomeu of not respecting club rules. His selected Managing Committee exceeded their powers when they signed Arda Turan. The continuous sneaky and blatant disregard of rules has become a pattern with Josep Maria Bartomeu and one only has to fear what lies ahead if he is elected in the upcoming Barça presidential elections.

With Barça capturing the treble for an unprecedented second time, it was time for me to take a break, and enjoy the summer with a move to Florida along with Copa America and Gold Cup action before thinking of the next Barça season. However, with the Barça presidential candidates finally being announced, it was hard not to pay attention again to the on-goings in Barcelona.

Promises are usually made by candidates on who will be signed if they are elected. However, the fact that the club’s Managing Committee was able to sign Arda Turan during elections is preposterous. Only one candidate wanted Arda Turan, after failing miserably in getting Pogba, and suddenly that player was signed by the club under the guise of necessity. That candidate is none other than Josep Maria Bartomeu.

The functions of the Managing Committee are defined under Article 35.4 of the club’s statutes as the following:

“The Managing Committee will perform all governmental, administrative and representative functions that are normally attended to by the Board of Directors. It shall limit its acts to those that are necessary and essential in order to maintain the club’s regular activities and to protect the club’s interests.”

Throughout the years, we have had numerous presidential elections, yet I have never seen a Managing Committee overreach its powers and sign or sell a player during this period. Since when did it become necessary and essential for the club to sign a player when elections are just right around the corner? The club’s regular activities and protecting club’s interests seems pretty basic to me. Make sure that the employees f the club are getting their paychecks and also make sure the bills get paid on time so the power is not turned off at the Camp Nou. Anything else can wait until a new president is elected.

The fact that this signing took place is not a surprise when it was Bartomeu who hand selected the Managing Committee. Sure, the transfer included a return policy that will cost the club a few million euros if the new president refuses to honor this deal which makes it possible to revoke this deal but is it worth the cost? The excuse that Luis Enrique wanted this player does not carry much weight. If that is what he wanted, then wait till a new president is elected before asking for the player to be signed. This deal seemed forced since Arda and Atlético did not appear to impatient in waiting for Barça to make this move, so why make this move so quickly? This is so shady but then again, we have become accustomed to shadiness these past few years under Rosell and now Bartomeu.

La Liga’s disciplinary committee lacks discipline.

La Liga has found itself in another ridiculous situation when it comes to players’ lack of self-control and the league’s failure to properly discipline them. If the league wants to set an example by punishing players, then they need to wake up and revamp its disciplinary committee. January saw the return of La Liga football after the winter break and we already have seen some players commit terrible acts on the pitch that are worthy of a lengthy ban. Yet, we are left wondering why that is not the case. Ronaldo was given a two match ban after getting sent off against Cordoba last week for losing his mind and kicking and punching Edimar when the score was 1-1.

Many were not surprised that he was not given a lengthy ban. La Liga has always been known to be lax when it comes to disciplining players, especially those from the big clubs. A few days ago, we saw two bizarre incidents in the Copa del Rey clash between Atlético Madrid and Barça. In the second half, Arda Turan lost his cool, after getting fouled by Dani Alves, and proceeded to pick up his boot off the ground and toss it at the linesman. If that was not bizarre enough, what happened next was even more bizarre. The referee gave Arda Turan a yellow card. Perhaps if the boot had struck the linesman, it would have warranted a red.

Don’t be surprised if Arda Turan will not be punished for this outrageous conduct since the referee report will show that the player was booked. The league’s disciplinary committee relies on the referee’s final report which in itself is a problem and not on secondary evidence. During that Cordoba Real Madrid match, Ronaldo had earlier gotten away with punching Cordoba player Jose Angel Crespo. Even though everyone else saw it, the three officials on the pitch did not and he was not punished for it. Better yet, it was not even taken into consideration when the two match ban was handed down by the disciplinary committee. Thus, if the referee did not report it, it did not happen and will not be taken into consideration.

The league’s disciplinary committee needs to adopt the Premier League’s model when it comes to punishing players for aggressive conduct. Former La Liga troublemaker, Diego Costa, was recently given a three match ban for stamping Emre Can, even though the referee did not spot it. The FA’s decision mentioned that “[t]he incident was not seen by the match officials but caught on video.” Another perfect example was when FIFA rightfully banned Luis Suarez for biting Giorgio Chiellini, even though the referee failed to spot the disgusting act, thanks to what they saw on video. If this measure is good enough for FIFA and the Premier League, then it should be good enough for La Liga to adopt. La Liga’s disciplinary committee needs to become strict if it really cares about its young viewers who are watching their games.

Ronaldo has been sent off five times during his time with Real Madrid. Out of those five, four were for aggressive conduct and he got away with just a booking when he and Godin engaged in a quick slug fest during the Spanish Super Cup. Perhaps it’s time the league cracked down on players by increasing the ban on repeat offenders to act as a deterrence or else we will continue to see players get sent off for aggressive conduct; that’s if they do get sent off like what we saw with Arda Turan. Allowing a player to get the same punishment for the same type of aggressive conduct over and over again for losing their cool does not send a proper message to the players and the fans is not acceptable.

In conclusion, La Liga’s disciplinary committee needs to get with the times and rely on video evidence. If the referee failed to punish Turan for what he did, then they need to rectify that problem themselves. Furthermore, the league’s disciplinary committee needs to punish repeat offenders in a stricter manner to deter players from losing their calm. The league needs to be conscious of its image both across the world and domestically or continue to be mocked for lacking the discipline to get things done right.