In Rosell We Trust?

Sandro Rosell’s era as FC Barcelona president has seen the club enjoy success on the pitch with domestic and international titles. However, Rosell has not been enjoying the same success off the pitch. His presidency has been clouded with controversial decisions that have finally reached a limit with certain club members. It seems that for some members, the time has come for Rosell to face the music with a censure motion to be served upon Rosell and three of FC Barcelona Vice-Presidents tomorrow.

Just to set the record straight, I have never been a fan of Sandro Rosell. I despised him the minute he stepped down as FC Barcelona Vice-President and published a tell all book to sully then President Joan Laporta and reveal dirt about the club such as their flirtation with firing Frank Rijkaard during his first season and replace him with Luiz Felipe Scolari and Rijkaard not wanting Ronaldinho to be signed. I wouldn't expect that from someone who loves the club. He sure didn’t look flattering in that BBC documentary “The Inside Story” where he came off a bit drunk with power along with acting as if he was the president at times while also coming off as a whiner  exhibiting the victim mentality that Barça fans were associated with in the past when he was complaining about referees robbing Barça. I never understood his comment that clubs run by president in a dictatorial manner was a successful approach since he complained that Laporta was doing the same thing after Rosell stepped down.

I was planning on writing this blog as part of the third and final chapter of my summer trilogy following “In La Masia We Trust?” and “In Tito We Trust?”. However, Tito’s unfortunate news of his cancer returning made me put off lambasting Rosell until now. In Rosell we trust? Based on the reaction of Blaugrana faithful inside the Camp Nou and on the social media, I guess not. Rosell promised a lot of things with transparency being one of the main promises. However, his presidency so far has been clouded with many deals that have not been transparent.

As much as the club has been successful on the pitch during Rosell’s presidency, his term has been very controversial. Some of the decisions that he made range from changing the rules in becoming a member, “Socio”, of the club to the Qatar Foundation sponsorship deal forced upon the club without members voting on it first. Some also blame him for Pep Guardiola walking away from the club while others complain that he has used his presidency for applying petty revenge against Laporta. The idea to allow a Madrid based media company to handle Barça TV turned out to be a bad idea when a video leaked Xavi’s off the record comments about Real Madrid which embarrased the player.

Furthermore, the club under his era has seen some awful decisions when it comes to players such as selling David Villa for peanuts while reneging on a promise to bring back Abidal and allowing him to leave which meant the club lost a positive and rallying influence in the clubhouse. By the way, Abidal has looked great for Monaco thus far. The Thiago fiasco that saw him join Bayern Munich because the lack of minutes for the young player resulted in his buyout clause to significantly decrease was also poorly handled. The way the youth setup is being run by bringing back Eusebio and not buying a centerback the past two seasons.

For a president, his actions have resulted in a lot of foot in mouth moments such as when he said the club would reduce spending by no longer allowing color printing and his poor responses to that poor excuse of an interview with TV3 when he was questioned about receiving payments from Brazilian friendlies. He also has enraged some of the fans with his decision to replace the Camp Nou with a new stadium proposal, lying about his ties with the Boixos Nois, allegedly contemplating suing a Socio for his tweets about his presidency, making excuses about Thiago’s buyout clause being misreported by the media, his lack of action against the media whenever Pep and the players were attacked but not when he was, lack of transparency about the Neymar transfer payments, and the list goes on and on.

Well, it seems that many have had enough of Sandro Rosell and his shady ways of running this club. The group “Go Barça” which consists of FC Barcelona Socios will bring a censure motion to against Rosell and Vice Presidents Jordi Cardoner, Josep María Bartomeu, Javier Faus, and Carles Vilarrubí. The people at Total Barça have a great story describing the reasons behind this action from “Go Barça”. It seems that the final straw was Rosell’s interview about the Brazilian friendlies payments controversy. So this action will be presented tomorrow which requires obtaining signatures from of 5% of the Socios which amounts to about 7,000 Socios. Of course, Rosell had already proposed changes to that measure by raising that percentage to 15%. It seems like he saw the writing on the wall but won’t have a chance to implement in time.

So brace yourselves fans; this is going to get ugly. Laporta-Cruyff fans versus Rosell fans and the mud-slinging and accusations will be tossed left and right. Pity that this could tarnish a great start by the club but sometimes the fans cannot accept or tolerate a presidency that is run on broken promises and lack of transparency. Rosell should know, he was allegedly one of the behind the scenes players in Laporta’s Censure Motion. Like the old saying goes, “What goes around, comes around” and it is Rosell’s turn to sit on the hot seat and see who jumps ship.

 

La Liga’s Big Two ~ Politics Only Hurts Themselves.

Over the years, Barça and Real Madrid have had their battles on the pitch through their players and off the pitch through the clubs’ hierarchy. More recently however, both clubs have been engaging in political battles to their own detriment. The politics are damaging their own clubs on the pitch for now and the future.

A new La Liga season is upon us and with that comes the usual talk about the El Clásico sides fighting for the title, although Atlético Madrid has earned the right to enter the mix this season. As usual, we will be bombarded by the usual unsubstantiated rumors and gossip from both cities’ press, which never hides their allegiance to the big two. However, we are also witnessing a strange phenomenon where both clubs are engaging in political warfare that is only damaging to themselves and not to their rivals.

Mourinho and Iker Casillas’s falling out was one of the world’s worst kept secret during last season. It was normal to expect Casillas back in the starting lineup for this season. However, that has not been the case as Casillas has been relegated back to the bench this season. This relegation came amid rumors that some of the Madrid directors were not too pleased with his role in the breakdown of the Mourinho relationship with the players, clubs and fans. Madrid directors can feel that they are off the hook after Casillas suffered an injury in their first Champions League match and can now watch Diego Lopez play in all competitions until Casillas returns. Yet, it does beg the question of why would the club treat an icon like Casillas this way and still expect him to stick around.

Moreover, Madrid displayed another decision that smacked of the clubs’ hierarchy making the on field decisions. Gareth Bale was signed by the club without a proper preseason this summer to stay fit. Instead of bringing him along gradually, Madrid opted to start him from the get go. Sure, he notched a goal in his debut before he had to be replaced when the fatigue factor kicked in. So it came as no surprise when Bale suffered an injury while warming up over the weekend for his next league start. Madrid’s decision to show off their star player without giving him proper time to get in shape was misguided and dangerous to their own players’ health. Perhaps they should let the manager make these decisions.

Barça too have had their own self-inflicted wounds due to the political stance of the clubs’ hierarchy against the last Barça president Joan Laporta and Barça icon Johan Cruyff. Sandro Rosell’s agenda has driven a wedge between the fans as he continues to wage his battle against Laporta. Some would say that this same agenda is the reason why Guardiola is currently managing Bayern Munich. As former Barça handball player and potential president candidate, Enric Masip, recently lamented the poor relationship Rosell has with former Blaugrana managers. Masip was obviously alluding to the fact that this current Barça president does not get along with the three managers who helped guide Barça to Champions League success.  One would expect the complete opposite after the success Cruyff, Rijkaard and Pep brought to the club.

Some also attribute the club’s hierarchy as the reason why Victor Valdés is looking for a new team for next season. Apparently, Valdés wanted Spain’s national team goalkeeper coach, José Manuel Ochotorena, to hold the same position with Barça when the position became available last summer. However, the club, via Zubizarreta, shot that option down and instead hired José Ramón de la Fuente. The reason behind that purported decision stemmed from Ochotorena’s Real Madrid past. Of course, José Ramón de la Fuente’s Barça history probably also played a part in his hiring. So the club’s ideology has probably cost them the best keeper in their entire history and that is a position that took over a decade to replace.

Will other players jump ship if Rosell continues to have his way and continue to drive the wedge deep between the fans? The decision not to bring Abidal back for at least one season smacked of ignorance and disgrace. Furthermore, Iniesta did not sign Barça’s first renewal offer and one of my friends did remind me that Iniesta’s best friend and the guy he sits next to on every flight is none other than Valdés.  I’m sure they’ve had a few things to discuss about the club’s hierarchy.

In the end, it would be best if the directors of clubs would do their jobs and not engage in deciding who starts and who sits. Also, it wouldn’t hurt if those same directors would exercise some proper judgment and lead the club without engaging in petty revenge to the detriment of the supporters. These types of decisions only reflect poorly on the club and can be detrimental to their own image. For now, only time will tell before we see the lasting impact of both clubs’ behind the scenes antics.

Barça’s Young Defenders’ Quandary.

Another season with a new manager yet the outcome for Barça’s young defenders Martin Montoya and Marc Bartra remains unchanged.  The duo have been rotating their seats with the bench and the stands. With the season now rolling into the insane cycle of two games a week, these young players have to play. The club cannot take for granted that since they came through La Masia, these players will not complain and seek an exit. Such wishful thinking could lead to familiar problems yet again.

Thiago was a perfect example of players exhibiting ambition by seeking a new change in order to gain minutes. Many assumed that Thiago would stay put and accept being a bench player who hardly features since he came through La Masia and thus, was loyal. The club then saw the young phenom pack his bags and head to Bayern Munich. Barça face the same dilemma with their two young defenders Montoya and Bartra. Both have hardly featured this season when they should be.

It’s no surprise that there have been media reports that the young players are upset at their lack of playing time which is why they are reluctant to sign new deals with the club. Some would say that they should be patient and their moment will come. Some attributed that same argument to Thiago and complained that he should have been patient like his peers Xavi and Iniesta. However, those two did not have legends playing ahead of them and actually made more appearances at Thiago’s age than he did.

Bartra has also been rotating from bench and the stands. He is the number one choice if either Pique or Mascherano get hurt. Yet, he has not played since representing Spain this summer. One would expect the club to learn from last season’s mistakes of not giving the young defender more playing time to prevent him from making an appearance in case of an injury to one of the center backs, while in a rusty condition. Based on the situation, I thought Bartra did the best that he could against Bayern seeing as he was not constantly playing. However, if Puyol is to make a healthy return, where would Bartra’s minutes come from?

Yesterday, Montoya was on the bench and Bartra was in the stands collecting rust yet again. The club made the big mistake of not signing center backs this summer and so they need to rotate as much as they can in a season as this where the calendar is congested with far too many games without ample time for rest. This is when you depend on the youth to give the veterans some games to rest and keep everyone healthy.

We will soon see whether Tata will go ahead and implement those moves. If not, then expect these young players to continue to be frustrated and perhaps seek an exit in the winter transfer window. That could spell trouble for the club and could also cast a negative reflection for the young players with Barça B who might contemplate their futures too.

Barça paying for transfer neglect.

An apparent need for Barça to strengthen its back line was discussed plenty this past summer. Yet, here we are, another season without any viable re-enforcements to protect Valdés’s first line of defense. Consequently, we have seen our beloved Barça continue their habit of conceding soft goals much to the dismay of many players and fans alike. Doubts about this club’s problems disappearing anytime soon have crept up again which begs the question why was this problem not addressed again.

Two summers ago, Barça were going to sign a center back and it didn’t happen. This past summer, Barça huffed and puffed and were going to sign a center back and it didn’t happen. We have a new manager and we’re seeing the same mistakes happening plaguing Barça’s defending. Cheap soft goals conceded at the end of a half or close to the final whistle have raised doubts if this club can eradicate last season’s performances against Real Madrid and Bayern Munich.

The Champions League kicks off this week and with it, comes the difficult calendar that sees Barça playing featuring in plenty of midweek games which cuts down on the valuable rest between matches. Rotations of the players is vital to preserve the players but our back four are down to just five players now that Jordi Alba is out of action for three weeks. Thus, we’re stuck with Dani Alves, Montoya, Pique, Mascherano, Bartra and Adriano with the return of captain Puyol supposedly near the corner. Will this be adequate for the club to compete in all competitions or will they sign some new players to strengthen the back four? If so, the question would be who?

Sandro Rosell and Zubizarreta better start looking into this issue. Many would mention names of players but perhaps the club needs to re-examine their scouts. Why is it that the likes of Porto and Dortmund can sign players that many clubs become obsessed in signing while Barça buy the likes for Alex Song? I don’t expect Puyol’s return to cure the problems and that is why Barça needs to address this issue now in time for January or for next season.

Barça cannot allow this pattern to continue. Failing to address this issue yet again is a recipe for disaster and Barça have already been warned. Failure to do so is unfair to the fans and the players when the talents of Messi, Iniesta, Neymar and others are wasted because this team cannot protect a lead. Zubizarreta and the club are on notice; fix this issue.